Skip to content
Home » Content

Nearly a Year Later, ACLU Files Suit Against DPD for Black Bloc Mass Arrest

August 21, 2009 by BringItDownNow

ACLU News Release

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:  August 20, 2009

CONTACT:   John Culver, ACLU Cooperating Attorney, 303-716-0254

Mark Silverstein, ACLU Legal Director, 303-777-5482 ext 114

 Denver sued for indiscriminate mass arrest during DNC; class action claim also alleges Denver illegally denied arrestees access to attorneys

Just days before the anniversary of a mass arrest that shut down a downtown protest march during the Democratic National Convention (DNC) last year, eight Plaintiffs represented by lawyers for the ACLU of Colorado filed suit last evening in Denver District Court against Denver and high-ranking police officials.  The Plaintiffs, who include a legal observer for the People’s Law Project (PLP), a journalist,  students documenting the march , and peaceful onlookers who observed the march legally from the sidewalks, assert that they were falsely arrested without probable cause and groundlessly prosecuted for crimes they did not commit, in violation of the First and Fourth Amendments. 

In an additional claim filed as a class action on behalf of nearly one hundred persons, the ACLU charges that Denver illegally prohibited the Plaintiffs and others held at the City’s special DNC detention center from meeting with attorneys who came to provide legal advice and consultation after the mass arrest.   

            “With regard to policing protest during the DNC, Denver police sometimes got it very right, for which they deserve credit,” said Mark Silverstein, ACLU Legal Director.  “On this evening, however, Denver police got it wrong, very wrong.   Although Denver often allows street marches to proceed without the required permit, the police chose to crack down on this one.  But police failed to distinguish between street marchers and others who were participating or merely observing from the sidewalks, where they had a legal right to be.  If there is a case where a large and potentially raucous public gathering threatens to get out of hand, police can issue orders to disperse and clear the area, but no such order was issued that night.” 

The march started from Civic Center Park in the early evening of August 25, 2008.  Participants marched on 15th Street and the adjoining sidewalks but were quickly stopped by a solid line of  police at Court Street.  A second line of police-- clad in full body riot armor and carrying an array of less-lethal weapons--quickly closed in from behind, confining hundreds of persons in a one-block stretch of 15th Street between Court and Cleveland.   The encircled group included not only the street marchers, but also participants who had been marching legally on the public sidewalks, as well as legal observers, curious onlookers, members of the press, and other nonparticipants.  This large group was detained a substantial time between police lines while Denver’s top officials decided what to do.

According to the lawsuit, Denver carried out an arbitrary and groundless mass arrest of an entire group of 96 individuals, knowing that the roundup included numerous innocent persons such as the ACLU’s clients.  Indeed, of the 54 persons who did not accept an immediate plea bargain, at least 38 were exonerated after jury trials or after prosecutors finally dismissed charges.  Although officers at the scene completed statements under oath recounting “facts” that supposedly justified each of the Plaintiff’s arrests, the lawsuit charges that these sworn statements were “universally and materially false.” 

“The arresting officers consistently swore that Plaintiffs were marching in the street and that they ignored audible orders to disperse issued by a police supervisor,” said John Culver, of Culver & Benezra, LLC, who is litigating the case as an ACLU cooperating attorney, along with his partner Seth Benezra.  “As Denver later acknowledged, however, no order to disperse was ever issued.  Our clients did not participate in the march in the street, and police never provided them with any opportunity to leave the area.”

The ACLU asserts that its clients were falsely arrested and forced to defend themselves in court proceedings from groundless accusations of criminal conduct.  All  were charged with failing to obey a police order to disperse.  After Denver finally acknowledged that no such order had ever been issued, City attorneys nevertheless persisted in prosecuting the Plaintiffs for allegedly “obstructing” a public right of way by marching in the street without a permit.   With legal representation from the PLP, all the criminal cases have now been resolved in the Plaintiffs’ favor, either through dismissals or acquittals after jury trials.  

After their arrest, the Plaintiffs and most of the arrestees were locked into holding cells at a vacant warehouse that Denver converted into a detention facility for DNC-related arrests .   At the warehouse, which protesters dubbed “Gitmo on the Platte,”  Denver refused to allow attorneys to meet with or speak with any of the arrestees.   

            The lawsuit relies on a longstanding Colorado statute that requires custodians of detention facilities to allow attorneys to meet with detainees in a confidential setting.  The law provides for penalties of up to one thousand dollars for each violation.   This claim is filed as a class action, and the ACLU lawyers ask that the statutory penalty be imposed on behalf of all the persons swept up in the August 25 mass arrest who were held at the City’s detention facility.

“Prior to the DNC, the ACLU advised Denver on multiple occasions that Colorado law required them to accommodate attorney visits at the detention facility, but Denver officials insisted that no attorney visits would be permitted," said Taylor Pendergrass, ACLU Staff Attorney.  "This lawsuit challenges Denver's willful decision to deny an entire class of persons a basic right long protected by Colorado law--to consult with an attorney at any place of custody.  Denver officials had no legitimate basis for treating the detention facility as a legal black hole where this fundamental Colorado law  did not apply."

            Plaintiffs in the lawsuit are Nathan Acks, Tiffany Bray, Chase Goll, Eli Hardy, Aminah Masud, Ian Morrison, Blake Pendergrass, and Kim Sidwell.  Defendants include Denver as well as police Commander Deborah Dilley and Sgts. Anthony Foster and Anthony Martinez. 

In addition to Culver, Benezra, Silverstein and Pendergrass, the Plaintiffs’ legal team includes ACLU Cooperating Attorney Lonn Heymann, of Rosenthal and Heymann LLC, who also represented arrestees in their criminal cases on behalf of the PLP. 

The Complaint, pre-DNC correspondence between the ACLU and Denver regarding the issues raised in the lawsuit, and other materials are available on the ACLU’s website at http://www.aclu-co.org/docket/200822/200822_description.html.

 

--end--

The ACLU is a nationwide, non-profit, non-partisan organization dedicated to defending and preserving the principles of the Bill of Rights through litigation, advocacy and public education.  The ACLU Foundation of Colorado works to protect the rights of all Coloradoans.

Permalink

Comments

Is this you Nathan?

August 21, 2009 by phil, 13 weeks 3 days ago
Comment id: 3824

The thrird to the last paragph reads as follows:

Plaintiffs in the lawsuit are Nathan Acks, Tiffany Bray, Chase Goll, Eli Hardy, Aminah Masud, Ian Morrison, Blake Pendergrass, and Kim Sidwell.  Defendants include Denver as well as police Commander Deborah Dilley and Sgts. Anthony Foster and Anthony Martinez. 

I have only one question, is this our Nathan? 

His picture

August 21, 2009 by BringItDownNow, 13 weeks 3 days ago
Comment id: 3825

Was in the Denver post this morning as well. Took me kind of by surprise!

What Can I Say...?

August 22, 2009 by Nathan Acks, 13 weeks 2 days ago
Comment id: 3834

...It's me.

To be perfectly honest, I could have gone through my entire life without having been arrested and have been perfectly happy. What really makes me mad, though, is the stories I heard from other arrestees after I bonded out and headed back to the PLP offices to help out that night. For me, that's the real purpose of this lawsuit: The DPD was completely off the hook during the DNC, and needs to do some serious thinking about its policies and what behaviors it encourages (either explicitly or implicitly) within its ranks.

There are, of course, many other problems with the DPD, and far more egregious things have happened to other folks than happened to me or my fellow plaintiffs that night. But I can only be part of a case where the DPD wronged me. I encourage those who have been wronged at other times to seek redress and change as well.

Protest is an important part of the social discourse, but society doesn't turn on a dime, and I think it's important to use all of the tools at our disposal, whether they're "officially sanctioned" (like lawsuites) or not. Different tactics incur differing consequences, differing responses, and differing amounts of risk. Not all of us are comfortable - or believe - in every action that can be taken, and we must decide the form of our involvement and who we support for ourselves. This is part of my battle; others must decide the battles they are willing to fight, and the weight of consequences they are willing to carry, for themselves.

For those who were arrested

August 24, 2009 by BringItDownNow, 13 weeks 10 hours ago
Comment id: 3841

And you want to get involved or are looking for information you should call the local ACLU chapter in Denver. Leave a voicemail with the relevent information and they should get back to you and send you some stuff.

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
Sorry we have to ask, but are you a spammer?
agricu_ture:

Open Newswire

Health Bill Ignores Industrial Health Harms
34 min 42 sec ago
Anonymous

(Actually, this is for all Colorado and all of the country. Why's that option not there in the "Region" box?)

Health care bill, now in hands of the Senate, ignores every industrial threat and harm to health. It finds that people's behavior is the biggest threat. Could this be because all Senators are economically-linked to health-harming industries, AND their insurers and investors? Sworn and public-paid Congress members wouldn't go AWOL on their solemn oaths and duties to the people, would they?

If it were not for people, there would be no Health Crisis.

The legislation the Senate is discussing now is quite interesting and telling by what's there, or not.

See the Bill at: democrats.senate.gov/reform/patient-protection-affordable-care-act.pdf

A convenient search tool at the site finds the number of times a word appears in the legislation:

Nutrition 29 times
Tobacco 25
Smoking 11
Obesity 9
Exercise 9
Behavior 8
Lifestyle 5
Alcohol 2

However:

Pesticides 0
Insecticides 0
Herbicides 0
Dioxins 0
Mercury 0
Chemicals 0
Carcinogen(s) 0
Chlorine 0
Radiation 0
Depleted Uranium 0
Salmonella 0
Pollutant(s) 0
Pollution 0
Vehicle exhaust 0
Smog 0
E-coli 0
Asbestos 0
Toxins 0
Toxic 0
Hazardous waste 0

And... Marijuana 0
Condoms 0
Vegetarian 0
Organic(s) 0

There seems to be a theme here, perhaps aimed at reassuring us that private industries, especially investment properties of for-profit insurers, are no threat to health. That is off the radar. Nothing to worry about or act on there.
We (the) people are the problem.
FREE GLUCOSE METERS + AMERICAN DREAM PROGRAM FREE 800 306 0990 24HRS
6 hours 16 min ago
Anonymous

Government Diabetes.Org located in Washington, DC has reported, "There are free watches for every state plus billions of dollars in assistance earmarked for people previously diagnosed as diabetic. Public and private funds are now available for them to repair homes, start a business, consolidate debts and any worthwhile purpose." In addition, he reported how new financial resources have been committed to help diabetics get job training and re-enter the job market.
"Now is the time for diabetics to act if they need money, Wall Street has no effect on theses funds," urged Greene. He also revealed that several reduced-cost and free programs now exist to help diabetics and the economically disadvantaged who have been diagnosed with diabetes. Such programs include energy assistance, free prescriptions, free diabetic watch,home repair and legal aid.

Free-Glucose-Meter-Rx.Com offers the free diabetic watch program that provides the latest information on assistance for diabetics. It covers job training, financial assistance, phone bill assistance, diabetic recipes, free grants, scholarship and loan resources available for a wide variety of purposes, including business start-ups for diabetics. The kit also includes a list of more than fifteen hundred professionals offering diabetics free advice and business guidance.

For additional information on Government Diabetes.Org, contact Charles Greene or visit http://www.government-diabetes.org http://www.free-glucose-meter-rx... , Diabetic-Testing-Supplies.Orgfor news on diabetes visit , http://www.free-diabetic-supplie... . . Government Diabetes.Org offers a free diabetics watch and a free glucose meter to qualified beneficiaries with diabetes. Free diabetic watch offers are available in all 50 states while supplies last.
Zhibin Gu: China entrepreneurship, open society revolution vs Communist dynasty: history, politics, economy, and corruption
21 hours 19 min ago
Anonymous

George Zhibin Gu summarizes the history of China's Communist Dynasty:

(George Zhibin Gu of China is an author of several new books, including: 1. China's global reach, 2. China and the new world order, 3. Made in China.)

The past 60 years of China's Communist history can be divided roughly into two phases.

The first phase, between 1949 and 1978, was this: the Communist bureaucracy had totally destroyed society, the economy and the culture. This was done by a total bureaucratic monopoly over all of nation's wealth, labor, markets, organizations and institutions. Furthermore, it completely destroyed the free press and the law. But this unprecedented bureaucratic domination immediately produced unprecedented man-made disasters in world history, not just China's. The disasters include endless violence and terror, the creation of the state sector and people's communes, the total bureaucratization of media, education, and thought.

In the end, beginning in 1958, the regime wanted to have a total bureaucratic miracle in the so-called Great Leap Forward (1958-60), and record disasters emerged all at once. Record deaths of some 50 million people occurred in the period of 1958-62, killing some 50 million people by an unprecedented famine as well as a record oganized violence.

What is more, these unprecedented miseries turned out to be the very beginning of bureaucratic disasters. Worse than the famine, three bureaucratic wars emerged against society and the people in the period of 1959-78, which ended to destroy countless millions of lives, or even more, by organized violence, not to mention a near total destruction of culture, education, thinking, wealth and all other good things in life.
Responding to Harmful Government Inaction, Protestors Stop Blasting on Coal River Mountain
2 days 9 hours ago
Anonymous

PETTUS, W. Va. – Early this morning two concerned citizens, Dea Goblirsch and Nick Martin, locked down to a drill rig on Coal River Mountain’s Bee Tree mountaintop removal site, effectively stopping blasting. Two others, Grace Williams and Laura Von Dolen, joined them in direct support, holding a banner with the message “Save Coal River Mountain”.

These nonviolent protestors have taken this action to bring attention to the extreme danger facing residents of the Coal River Valley from blasting near the Brushy Fork Impoundment. They plan to stay locked down until law enforcement removes them.

Resident of Rock Creek, W Va., Delbert Gunnoe, stated his concerns with the blasting, “You know when they put a blast over there, and it shakes the windows over here, at what, ¾-a-mile distance, imagine what it does over there.” Gunnoe continued, “if [the impoundment] did bust…what would be the destruction? The town of Whitesville would no longer exist.”

The four are fearful of the blasting that Massey Energy began in late October. These blasts are 200 feet from the Brushy Fork Impoundment, permitted to hold nine billion gallons of toxic coal slurry. The impoundment sits atop miles of hollow, abounded underground mines, further endangering its integrity. By Massey’s own estimates, roughly 998 people will die should the dam break. The emergency evacuation plan states that a 40-foot wall of sludge, cresting at 72 feet, will flow through the valley, reaching 20-feet-high about 15 miles down the road. Apart from the initial flood, the impact of this potential spill would be felt along the Coal River’s 88 miles.
EVIDENCE THAT UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS WELCOMES FBI INTEL OPERATIONS AGAINST WHISTLEBLOWER
3 days 9 hours ago
gsosbee

The universities across the nation (and AG) do more for the fbi/cia than assist in the search for foreign terrorists; today our colleges and universities directly encourage their campus police and civilian employees to engage in unlawful intel operations against whistleblower
GERAL SOSBEE.

 

 

 

In November, 2009, the Texas Attorney General (AG) grants near blanket authority (in Case number OR2009-16316 & Case ID#367454) to the University Of Texas Police (UTP) and Harlingen, Texas (HTP) Police to withhold from Open Records (OR) disclosure the key data in their possession relating to Geral Sosbee. The AG also states in each opinion that the AG has no authority beyond the scope of the OR statutes. The AG thus hides from his responsibility as a citizen and human being for civil and human rights violations behind the the OR guidelines ( which are designed to allow the police to engage in witch hunts, stalking, harassment, fraudulent stings and other crimes as I have documented at many pages of www.sosbeevfbi.com.) I have also provided the AG with evidence of ongoing felonies against my person (continuing in Texas and other locations for the past decade); by the AG letters referenced above the fbi now gains the AG approval and authority to use UT employees (including UTP) in efforts to silence or kill me; see for example the specifics of some of my reports at

http://www.sosbeevfbi.com/affidavit2007.html

 
Evening of Solidarity for Dr. Mutulu Shakur
3 days 9 hours ago
denverabc

An Evening of Solidarity for Mutulu Shakur
Presented by Denver and Aurora CopWatch, Sisters of Color United for Education, and Denver ABC

Saturday, November 28th
Sisters of Color 2895 8th Ave, Denver, CO (8th and federal across the street from the bus yard)
7:30-12ish
Sliding Scale 1-5$ (if you ain't got it don't let it stop you from coming)

Teach-in by Professor Ward Churchill

Live Music by:
Mike Wird
Ietef
Debajito (of Debajo Del Agua)

Hosted by Shareef Aleem

Please join us on Saturday, November 28th to stand in solidarity with Dr Mutulu Shakur before his appeals hearing on Monday, November 30th at the super-maximum Federal prison in Florence, CO.

Dr. Shakur is a New Afrikan (Black) man whose primary work has been in the area of health. He is a doctor of acupuncture and one of the most prolific, committed and conscious freedom fighters and political prisoners to whom the Black liberation struggle has given birth.

Since the age 16, Dr. Shakur has been a part of the New Afrikan
Independence Movement. As a part of this movement Dr. Shakur has been a target of the illegal Counterintelligence Program carried out by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (COINTELPRO). This was a secret police strategy used in the U.S. starting in the 1960's to destroy and neutralize progressive and revolutionary organizations. It is believed that Dr. Shakur's resistance to this program led to his arrest and trial.

"Straight ahead, stiff resistance"

contact info: 970.302.7349/miketruswell@yahoo.com
www.mutulushakur.com
www.dare2struggle.org
The Shortwave Report 11/20/09 Listen Globally
4 days 3 hours ago
Anonymous

 Dear Radio Friend,
The latest Shortwave Report (November 20) is up at the website
http://www.outfarpress.com/outfa... in both broadcast quality (13.3MB) and quickdownload or streaming form (4.9MB) (28:59)
(NEW! If you have access to Audioport.org there is a higher quality version posted up there {26.7MB} http://www.audioport.org/index.p...)
Water and Imperialism
4 days 7 hours ago
NickB

(www.raimd.wordpress.com)

Water is essential, in various ways, to all human activity. Water is something that humans, literally, cannot do without. Every human needs water in order live and to have a good life. Societies need water in order to be provide for the survival of their populations. Usable water, as a resource, is finite and distributed unevenly across the planet. Most societies have difficulty providing water to their populations, especially in the Third World. The inability to access water is referred to as the water crisis.
la virgen de Guadalupe y los curas
4 days 9 hours ago
Anonymous

LA VIRGEN DE LA GUADALUPE ES DE TODOS LOS MEXICANOS, NO DE LOS CURAS

La Conferencia del Episcopado Mexicano (CEM) no está de acuerdo en que los Mexicanos utilicemos a la Virgen de la Guadalupe, como sucedió en la marcha de SME el pasado 11 de noviembre (2009) por “manipular el sentimiento religioso”, se ha afirmado en varias ocasiones desde que concluyó la 88ª Asamblea Plenaria del CEM. Los curas, junto con los políticos y las grandes transnacionales se han adueñado de nuestro país y de nuestros símbolos.

¿Ya se les olvidó a los curas que la Virgen de Guadalupe es el único símbolo religioso auténticamente Mexicano? ¿Ya se les olvidó que ellos llegaron con Hernán Cortés a robar y a imponernos su cruz a sangre y fuego? La Virgen de Guadalupe es Tonantzin y es nuestra, aunque no les guste a los extranjeros como ellos.

Lo que los curas del CEM no quieren es que el pueblo Mexicano, unido al SME, siga la trayectoria de don Miguel Hidalgo y les arrebate la jugosa ganancia.

Yo les pido a los curas del CEM que ya no nos “salven”.
¡¡Larguense de aquí!! ¡¡Larguense!! ¡¡Larguense!! ¡¡Larguense!! ¡¡Larguense!! ¡¡Larguense de México y de todo este continente!!
Josefa Ortiz
http://josefaortiz.hpage.com/sme...

 
PRESIDENT OBAMA ~ TAX EXEMPT U.S. FOUNDATIONS OF OUR AMERICAN WEALTHY ELITE HAVE BECOME TAX EVASION FOUNDATIONS THAT NEED NEW FEDERAL GUIDLINES.....
5 days 5 hours ago
Anonymous

FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TAX EXEMPT SLUSH FUND CHARITIES(FOUNDATIONS) FOR OUR U.S. WEALTHY ELITE AMERICANS WE ALL KNOW  are QUITE COMMON AND COSTING THE U.S.GOVERNMENT BILLIONS IN POSSIBLE TAX REVENUE.

***MANY OF THESE SAME AMERICAN WEALTHY ELITE NOT ONLY HAVE FULL CONTROL OVER THEIRTX EVADING  FOUNDATIONS BILLIONS,BUT ALSO FIND IT NECESSARY TO HIRE LOBBYISTS TO ATTEMPT THE DIRECT CONTROL OVER VARIOUS USES OF AMERICAN TAX PAYERS TAX $$$ ???

WEALTHY ELITE AMERICANS HAVE COMPLETE CONTROL OVER OUR U.S.CONGRESSIONAL TAX DOLLAR SPENDING WITH THEIR BEHIND THE SCENE LOBBY MONIES... AND ARE CONTINUING TO DENY MIDDLE~CLASS AND WORKING POOR AMERICANS PROPER HEALTH ~ CARE , PROPER LEGAL PROTECTIONS IN AMERICAN FAMILY COURTS,CIVIL COURTS,& FEDERAL APPEALS FROM STATE COURTS. **THOUSANDS OF POORER AMERICANS ALL ACROSS AMERICA ARE LOSING PARENTING AND VISITATION RIGHTS WITH THEIR CHILDREN, ARE BEING FALSELY IMPRISONED, WRONGFULY EXECUTED,LOSING THEIR HOMES OR APARTMENTS ETC...

** IS THIS REALLY WHAT MANY SAY APPEARS TO BE THE FORMATION OF A NEW WORLD ORDER IN AMERICA THAT IS ATTEMPTING TO BREAK DOWN AND DESTROY AMERICAN FAMILIES AND ESTABLISHED FAMILY VALUES ACROSS OUR GREAT COUNTRY ???
more
AdaptiveThemes